Expanding a Clean Energy Company into the U.S. Why Your Directors and Your Engineers Might Need Different Visa Plans

Directors vs engineers: US visa plans for clean energy firms

Expanding a Clean Energy Company into the U.S. Why Your Directors and Your Engineers Might Need Different Visa Plans

Your clean energy company is investing in a U.S. operation, and you’re preparing to relocate both directors and engineers to inspect existing facilities, purchase and install new equipment, review procedures, and take over the running of the operation.

Your lawyers have been tweaking the purchase contract for months now. The roster of transferees has been honed, with interviews, meetings, family member planning sessions.

It’s time to get the actual people over to the U.S.  

Do directors and engineers need different U.S. visas for a clean energy expansion?

Not necessarily, but each person needs an individual assessment. Directors may qualify for E-2 or L-1A visas, while engineers may qualify as E-2 essential employees or L-1B specialized knowledge transferees. The appropriate visa depends on company structure, nationality, employment history and actual U.S. duties. Short installation or commissioning assignments qualify as business visits only when specific requirements are met.

Janice Flynn, a U.S. visa and nationality lawyer in the UK and Ireland

“As managing partner of Flynn Hodkinson, a firm with offices in London and Ireland focused exclusively on U.S. visa and nationality law, I have spent more than 20 years helping companies understand what their people can legally do in the United States. For a clean energy company, we start with the ownership structure, each person’s proposed duties and the supply contracts. If we need to tell a board that the visa around which they'd planned will not cover half the team, well, better to have that conversation before the flights are booked.”

One visa plan rarely covers the whole team

 False assumptions:

  • “We have the E-2, so everyone goes on the E-2”
  • “It’s only six weeks, they can go on ESTA”.

Facts:

  • U.S. immigration law assesses both the business and each person travelling. A qualifying company does not automatically qualify every employee. Directors and engineers may sometimes use the same visa category, but each person must meet the requirements for their proposed role. Job titles alone do not decide the visa.
  • There are two sets of tests:

               For directors (ownership, nationality, duties)

               For engineers (nationality, length of service, on-site work, length of stay)

Your directors: The visa follows ownership and role

A director’s visa is decided by who owns the U.S. company, the director’s nationality, and what they will run.

When the E-2 fits a director

  • For an E-2 employee application, the employer must meet the treaty-nationality requirements, including the applicable 50% ownership test. Ownership generally needs to be traced through holding companies to the ultimate individual owners. A UK or Irish registered office does not, by itself, establish the business’s nationality.
  • Where a corporation’s shares are traded exclusively on a stock exchange in its country of incorporation, consular guidance permits a presumption that its nationality follows that country. More complex ownership or listing arrangements require further analysis.
  • Both the United Kingdom and Ireland have qualifying E-2 treaty arrangements with the United States. Applicants relying on British nationality must also satisfy the UK treaty’s residence and domicile requirements; a British passport alone does not establish eligibility. Irish applicants qualify under Ireland’s separate treaty arrangements.
  • The director must share the company’s treaty nationality and either be the investor who develops and directs the business, or an employee in an executive or supervisory role.
  • A funding round or acquisition that reduces qualifying ownership below the required threshold can undermine the company’s ability to support E-2 employees of that nationality. Review the proposed ownership structure and the consequences for existing employees before the transaction closes.
  • Ownership and nationality are only part of the E-2 assessment. The investment must be substantial, with capital committed and at commercial risk, in a real business that is not marginal. A principal investor must demonstrate the ability to develop and direct the enterprise. An employee must independently qualify through executive or supervisory duties, or essential skills. E-2 applicants must also intend to depart when their E-2 status ends.
  • See: E-2 tips when buying a US business; acquiring a US company with a relocating MD.

 

When the L-1A fits better

  • L-1A may suit an employee transferring to a qualifying U.S. parent, branch, subsidiary or affiliate to work primarily as a manager or executive. The employee generally needs one continuous year of full-time employment abroad with a qualifying organisation within the relevant three-year period, in a managerial, executive or specialized knowledge capacity. For an L-1A new-office petition, the qualifying overseas employment must have been managerial or executive.
  • L-1 does not require the employee to share the company’s nationality, which helps when the right director is, for example, a Dutch national at the UK parent.
  • New office: initial approval of up to one year, so build the evidence for the extension (staff, premises, operations) from day one.
  • For L-1 purposes, a “new office” generally means an organisation that has been doing business in the United States for less than one year. Buying an established U.S. business does not automatically make it a new office.
  • Initial approval is limited to one year. The initial petition must show that the U.S. operation will support a managerial or executive position within that year; extension planning should begin before filing.
  • Dual intent is permitted; maximum stay seven years. Petition to USCIS on Form I-129, then visa interview.

Directors who only attend board meetings

  • A member of the board of a U.S. corporation may qualify as a business visitor to attend board meetings or perform genuine board functions. That permission does not extend to taking over the company’s day-to-day operations. The proposed activities and the traveller’s eligibility must still be assessed.
  • Job titles do not decide the visa
    • A UK company director may or may not perform “executive capacity” duties as U.S. law defines them. Duties, reporting lines and who they manage decide.
  • Start the green card plan with the visa plan
    • EB-1C multinational executive or manager: one year abroad in an executive or managerial role within the three years before the petition (or before entering the U.S. to work for the group), a qualifying relationship, and a U.S. company that has been doing business for at least one year. No labor certification.
    • That one-year clock starts when the U.S. company starts doing business, so the launch date matters for any director who intends to stay.
    • E-2 status does not automatically lead to permanent residence. An E-2 holder may qualify separately for an immigrant category but must meet that category’s requirements and plan around the E-2 intent-to-depart requirement.

Your engineers: the visa follows nationality, service and site work

For engineers, four questions decide the visa: what they will physically do on site, for how long, how long they have worked for you, and their nationality.

  1. Short trips to install, service or commission equipment
    • Eligible travellers may seek admission for permitted business activities using a B-1 visa or, where applicable, the Visa Waiver Program with approved ESTA authorisation. Visa Waiver Program visits are limited to 90 days. ESTA approval does not guarantee admission or authorise employment. A short assignment does not make otherwise prohibited work permissible.
    • The exception that matters here: installing, servicing or repairing commercial or industrial equipment bought from a company outside the U.S., or training US workers to do it. Conditions: the contract of sale requires the seller to provide the service, the engineer has knowledge essential to that obligation, and pay comes from outside the U.S.
    • Building or construction work, on-site or in-plant, is excluded. This provision excludes performing building or construction work. An otherwise eligible business visitor may qualify to supervise or train workers performing that work, but may not personally carry it out.
    • Commissioning must be assessed task by task. Testing or configuring supplied equipment may fall within the provision when all its conditions are met. Calling an assignment “commissioning” does not permit construction, general installation labour or ongoing operation of the facility. Activities such as civil works, installing structural racking or pulling building wiring raise construction concerns.
  2. E-2 essential skills employees
    • Engineers who share the enterprise’s qualifying treaty nationality may qualify as E-2 essential employees if their special qualifications are essential to its U.S. operations. An engineering title or general industry experience alone does not establish eligibility.
    • Consular officers weigh the experience and training behind the skills, how unique they are, whether U.S. workers have them, the salary they command and proven expertise.
    • Ordinarily skilled workers can qualify for start-up or training purposes, and the need may be time-limited while U.S. staff are trained.
    • Where the enterprise qualifies on British nationality, an otherwise eligible British engineer may qualify as an E-2 employee. A colleague who holds only Spanish or Indian nationality cannot qualify as an E-2 employee on that British treaty basis.
    • E-2 employees are not subject to L-1’s general one-year overseas-employment requirement.
  3. L-1B specialized knowledge
    • L-1B may suit a qualifying intracompany transferee with special knowledge of the organisation’s products, services or other interests and their application in international markets, or advanced knowledge of its processes and procedures. General engineering expertise alone does not establish eligibility.
    • For engineers employed by the group for one continuous year in the last three, with special knowledge of the company’s products, equipment, techniques or processes.
    • Any nationality. Maximum stay five years; new office approvals initially up to one year.
    • Clean energy examples: proprietary control software, an in-house electrolyser stack design, a specific turbine platform.
    • If the engineer will work primarily at an unrelated customer’s site, additional L-1B rules apply. The customer must not principally control and supervise the employee, and the placement must involve a product or service requiring the petitioning company’s specialized knowledge rather than supplying labour for hire.
    • A new hire who has not completed the required qualifying employment abroad will generally not yet qualify for L-1.
  4. When none of these fit
    • H-1B may be available for a qualifying specialty-occupation role. The annual allocation generally comprises 65,000 regular-cap places and an exemption for 20,000 qualifying U.S. advanced-degree holders. Cap-subject cases depend on the applicable registration and selection process, with employment generally beginning no earlier than 1 October of the relevant fiscal year. Cap-exempt cases follow different rules.
    • O-1A for engineers who meet the extraordinary-ability standard, including sustained national or international acclaim.
    • Nationality-specific visas: TN for Canadian and Mexican engineers under USMCA; E-3 for Australian nationals.

Note: These are realistic for some people and unrealistic for a fixed commissioning date, so they belong in the plan from the start.

Who goes first

Confirm the company structure and assess every proposed traveller early. Directors’ and engineers’ applications can often be prepared in parallel. The filing and travel sequence should follow the requirements of each visa and the project’s needs, rather than an assumption that directors must always go first.

  1. Confirm ownership of the US company by nationality, now and after the next funding round.
  2. List every traveler: nationality, date joined the group, on-site role, expected stay.
  3. Separate “run the business” from “build, install and commission”.
  4. Pull each supply and service contract: flag installation, servicing and training clauses.
  5. Confirm the appropriate consular post and E-2 enterprise documentation, or the relevant L-1 petition process, including whether new-office rules apply.
  6. Map engineers to business visits, E-2 essential skills, L-1B or another visa.
  7. Spouses admitted in qualifying E-2 or L-2 dependent status are authorised to work incident to that status. Their admission records should correctly reflect their spouse classification, normally E-2S or L-2S. Eligible unmarried children under 21 may accompany the principal applicant and study, but their dependent status does not authorise employment.
  8. EB-1C may be available to qualifying multinational managers and executives. It requires qualifying managerial or executive employment abroad for at least one year within the applicable three-year period, a qualifying relationship between the businesses, and a proposed managerial or executive role in the United States. The U.S. petitioning employer must have been doing business for at least one year. No labor certification is required, but eligibility and permanent-residence timing must be assessed separately.
  9. “Doing business” means providing goods or services regularly and continuously; incorporation or renting an office does not start the clock by itself.

Plan your people the way you plan your grid connection

Consider:  As a clean energy leader, you’re already managing long-lead, sequence-dependent items such as grid connection, permitting and equipment lead times. People moves should be managed the same way.

Not: “We’ll sort visas once the contract is signed.”

Ownership and length-of-service tests are set by decisions being made now.

If you’d like your U.S. team mapped, person by person, before anyone books a flight. Janice Flynn can review your ownership structure and travel list in a strategy consultation.

 

This post is for informational purposes only and is not intended as legal advice. If you require further assistance or advice relating to the above, please contact janice@flynnhodkinson.com.

Book an initial meeting with Janice Flynn
Frequently Asked Questions

1. Do directors and engineers need different U.S. visas when a clean energy company expands?

Not necessarily. Directors and engineers may qualify under the same visa category, but each person needs an individual assessment. For example, an eligible director might qualify as an E-2 executive employee, while an engineer qualifies as an E-2 essential employee. The company’s eligibility does not automatically qualify its staff. Actual duties, nationality, employment history and the business structure determine which options are available.

2. Can a clean energy engineer qualify for an E-2 visa?

Yes, an engineer may qualify as an E-2 essential employee if they share the enterprise’s qualifying treaty nationality and have special qualifications essential to its U.S. operations. An engineering title alone is insufficient. The assessment considers expertise, training, the business’s needs and the availability of the relevant skills in the United States. Unlike L-1, E-2 does not impose a general requirement for one year of previous overseas employment.

3. Can engineers install or commission equipment in the United States on ESTA or a B-1 visa?

Sometimes. A narrow business-visitor provision may cover installation, servicing or repair of commercial or industrial equipment purchased from an overseas company. The sales contract must specifically require the seller’s services, the engineer must possess unique knowledge essential to that obligation, and no U.S.-source remuneration may be received for the services. Construction work is excluded. “Commissioning” must be assessed task by task. Eligible Visa Waiver Program travellers also need approved ESTA authorisation and must observe the 90-day limit.

4. What is the difference between L-1A and L-1B for a clean energy team?

L-1A is for qualifying intracompany transferees whose U.S. duties are primarily managerial or executive. L-1B is for transferees with qualifying specialized knowledge, including special knowledge of the organisation’s products and their application in international markets, or advanced knowledge of its processes and procedures. A director’s title does not establish L-1A eligibility, and general engineering experience does not establish L-1B eligibility. Both routes require a qualifying relationship between the businesses.

5. How long must an employee have worked abroad before an L-1 transfer?

An employee generally needs one continuous year of full-time employment outside the United States with a qualifying organisation within the relevant three-year period. The overseas employment must have been in a managerial, executive or specialized knowledge capacity. A new hire without that qualifying employment will generally not yet qualify. Employment dates, overseas duties and time spent in the United States should be reviewed before relying on L-1.

6. Can an L-1B engineer work at a U.S. customer’s project site?

Potentially, but additional rules apply when an L-1B employee will work primarily at an unrelated customer’s site. The customer must not principally control and supervise the employee. The assignment must also involve supplying a product or service that requires specialized knowledge specific to the petitioning employer, rather than simply providing labour for hire. The contracts and actual working arrangements both matter.

7. Could a funding round affect our company’s E-2 eligibility?

Yes. Investment or ownership changes can affect the treaty-nationality requirements supporting E-2 employees. If qualifying ownership falls below the applicable 50% threshold, the company may no longer support those employees on the same treaty basis. Ownership generally needs to be traced to the ultimate individual owners. Review the proposed transaction before closing, including its consequences for existing employees and planned transfers.

8. Can a director attend U.S. board meetings as a business visitor?

A member of the board of a U.S. corporation may qualify as a business visitor to attend board meetings or perform genuine board functions. That does not authorise taking over the company’s day-to-day operations. A director travelling to manage the business needs an immigration classification permitting those duties. The distinction depends on the activities planned, rather than whether the person is described as an executive or non-executive director.

9. Must our directors obtain their visas before we apply for our engineers?

No general rule requires directors to obtain their visas first. Directors’ and engineers’ cases can often be prepared in parallel, although each route has its own business and individual eligibility requirements. Establish the company structure, proposed duties and supporting evidence early. The filing and travel sequence should reflect those requirements and the project timetable, rather than an assumption that one director’s approval authorises the rest of the team.

10. Does buying an existing U.S. business require an L-1 new-office petition?

Not automatically. For L-1 purposes, a new office generally means an organisation that has been doing business in the United States for less than one year. The acquisition date alone does not decide the issue. Where new-office rules apply, initial approval is limited to one year. An L-1A new-office petition must also demonstrate that the operation will support a managerial or executive position within that year.

11. Can the spouses and children of E-2 and L-1 employees accompany them?

Eligible spouses and unmarried children under 21 may apply for dependent status. Spouses in qualifying E-2 or L-2 status are authorised to work because of that status, without needing a separate employment authorisation document. Their Form I-94 should correctly identify their spouse classification, normally E-2S or L-2S. Dependent children may study, but their dependent status does not authorise employment. Family members’ eligibility and admission records should be checked individually.

12. Can an E-2 or L-1A director eventually obtain a U.S. green card?

Potentially, but neither classification automatically leads to permanent residence. EB-1C may suit a qualifying multinational manager or executive with the required overseas managerial or executive employment, a qualifying corporate relationship and a proposed managerial or executive U.S. role. The U.S. employer must have been doing business for at least one year. No labor certification is required, but all eligibility requirements must be met. E-2 holders must also plan around their intent-to-depart requirement.

Get U.S. Immigration Updates That Matter

Receive updates and articles on U.S. immigration for businesses, investors, families, and individuals in the UK and Ireland.